26/09/2017 09:15 AST

A claim by Dana Gas that it does not have to pay back its Islamic bonds because they are no longer sharia-compliant is “absurd” as repayment under such a scenario is covered in the original paperwork, creditors told a London High Court.

United Arab Emirates energy producer Dana Gas said in June that its $700 million sukuk were unlawful and unenforceable under UAE law and began proceedings to have this confirmed in British and UAE courts, because while the purchase undertaking part of the sukuk is regulated by English law, the “mudarabah” agreement underlying it is regulated by UAE law.

Mudarabah is a sukuk structure which resembles an investment management partnership.

The case has attracted the attention of the global Islamic finance industry as it could set a precedent for other sukuk issuers to refuse to redeem their debt obligations because of alleged changes in the interpretation of Islamic finance.

But the argument put forward by lawyers for fund manager BlackRock, reviewed by Reuters, argues that even in an unlikely scenario in which it could be shown that the mudarabah agreement could not be enforced under UAE law, Dana Gas would still be obliged to repay the sukuk under the purchase agreement.

In the trial in London, which began last week, legal representatives for BlackRock, which has some exposure to the Dana Gas sukuk, on Monday outlined their argument on its validity and enforceability to High Court judge George Leggatt.

Dana Gas and Deutsche Bank, one of the defendants and the delegate for the creditors, were not in court because of a last minute injunction obtained from a UAE court by some of Dana’s shareholders preventing them from taking part.

“In relation to each alleged mistake, the purchase undertaking provides, expressly or impliedly, that Dana Gas is to bear the relevant risk,” the document says.

“The alleged unlawfulness or unenforceability of the mudarabah agreement is one of the precise circumstances with which the (English law governed) purchase undertaking is intended to deal,” it adds.

Legal representatives for the creditors have asked the court to dismiss the Dana Gas claim and asked for permission to serve an exercise notice which would mean that if it does not pay back the sukuk principal, and the accrued unpaid profit rates, they would be able take action to ensure they were repaid.

Judge Leggatt said last week that after hearing BlackRock’s arguments he would adjourn the trial until Oct. 12 to see if the Sharjah court in the UAE would lift the injunction preventing Dana Gas and Deutsche from participating in the UK proceedings.


Dana Gas reports turnaround; $83m net profit for 2017


Dana Gas, the Middle East’s largest regional natural gas company, today reported full-year 2017 gross revenue and a net profit of $450 million and $83 million, respectively, compared to $392 million

Trade Arabia

Dana Gas gets $10.4m from sale of condensate


Dana Gas, the Middle East’s natural gas company, said it has received $10.4 million in February 2018 from the sale of 157,200 barrels of El Wastani condensate at an average price of $66.5 per barrel.

Gulf News

Dana Gas repeats challenge to English court sukuk ruling


Dana Gas will again challenge an English court judgment handed down in November against the company, as part of a widely-watched dispute with creditors over the non-payment of $700 million worth of s

The National

Ticker Price Volume
QNBK 135.21 176,223
SABIC 110.24 4,338,435
PETRORABIGH 24.75 1,456,662
BURUJ 34.51 80,357
ALMARAI 53.98 562,958
STC 78.66 497,315
CHEMANOL 10.33 4,467,717
DANA Sector Market
Relative Strength
  • 1-Month
  • 3-Month
  • 1-Year
Volume Change
  • 10D Avg Vs 90D Avg
Price Vs…
  • 52-w high
  • 50-day moving avg.
  • 200-Day Moving Avg
Ticker Price Change
PETRORABIGH 24.75 0.44 (1.80%)
BAHRI 31.49 0.00 (0.00%)
TAQA 0.72 0.04 (5.88%)
ADNOCDIST 2.65 0.04 (1.53%)
ALDREES 26.54 0.16 (0.60%)
Aramco’s US$7bil investment in Rapid by end of the month


The negotiation on Saudi Arabia Aramco’s US$7bil investment in Petroliam Nasional Bhd’s (Petronas) Refinery and Petrochemical Integrated Development (Rapid) project in Pengerang, Johor, has been conc

The Star

Oman Insurance Company to distribute 10% Dividend


Oman Insurance Company held its Annual General Assembly meeting yesterday which was presided over by H.E. Abdul Aziz Abdulla Al Ghurair, Chairman of the Board of Directors. The Board approved the pro

Press Release

Arkan Bank could tap investors for $100mln through Nasdaq listing


The new Islamic bank being set up by a group of investors led by Dubai Investments could raise up to $100 million within the first 12 months after its listing on Nasdaq Dubai, according to a senior o


Aldar and Emaar shares climb after Dh30bn strategic alliance


The shares of Aldar and Emaar Properties, two of the the UAE’s biggest developers, rose during early trade on Wednesday after unveiling a strategic alliance to develop local and international project

The National

Mobily is racing to a smarter future in partnership with Ericsson


ETIHAD Etisalat ‘Mobily’ in cooperation with Ericsson are preparing an IoT world program to be the first of its kind in the Kingdom that aims to create an interactive platform between university stud

Saudi Gazette