26/09/2017 09:15 AST

A claim by Dana Gas that it does not have to pay back its Islamic bonds because they are no longer sharia-compliant is “absurd” as repayment under such a scenario is covered in the original paperwork, creditors told a London High Court.

United Arab Emirates energy producer Dana Gas said in June that its $700 million sukuk were unlawful and unenforceable under UAE law and began proceedings to have this confirmed in British and UAE courts, because while the purchase undertaking part of the sukuk is regulated by English law, the “mudarabah” agreement underlying it is regulated by UAE law.

Mudarabah is a sukuk structure which resembles an investment management partnership.

The case has attracted the attention of the global Islamic finance industry as it could set a precedent for other sukuk issuers to refuse to redeem their debt obligations because of alleged changes in the interpretation of Islamic finance.

But the argument put forward by lawyers for fund manager BlackRock, reviewed by Reuters, argues that even in an unlikely scenario in which it could be shown that the mudarabah agreement could not be enforced under UAE law, Dana Gas would still be obliged to repay the sukuk under the purchase agreement.

In the trial in London, which began last week, legal representatives for BlackRock, which has some exposure to the Dana Gas sukuk, on Monday outlined their argument on its validity and enforceability to High Court judge George Leggatt.

Dana Gas and Deutsche Bank, one of the defendants and the delegate for the creditors, were not in court because of a last minute injunction obtained from a UAE court by some of Dana’s shareholders preventing them from taking part.

“In relation to each alleged mistake, the purchase undertaking provides, expressly or impliedly, that Dana Gas is to bear the relevant risk,” the document says.

“The alleged unlawfulness or unenforceability of the mudarabah agreement is one of the precise circumstances with which the (English law governed) purchase undertaking is intended to deal,” it adds.

Legal representatives for the creditors have asked the court to dismiss the Dana Gas claim and asked for permission to serve an exercise notice which would mean that if it does not pay back the sukuk principal, and the accrued unpaid profit rates, they would be able take action to ensure they were repaid.

Judge Leggatt said last week that after hearing BlackRock’s arguments he would adjourn the trial until Oct. 12 to see if the Sharjah court in the UAE would lift the injunction preventing Dana Gas and Deutsche from participating in the UK proceedings.


Reuters

Weeks of talks ‘fail to resolve Dana Gas sukuk dispute’

18/01/2018

Weeks of talks between UAE energy firm Dana Gas and some local holders of a disputed $700 million sukuk have failed to reach an agreement, sources told Reuters, leaving a potentially protracted legal

Arab News

Dana Gas' Sharjah Dec 25 court hearing adjourned, spokeswoman says

04/01/2018

Dana Gas, the Sharjah-based energy company currently embroiled in court battles over the legality of its US$700 million sukuk issuance, has had its December 25 hearing at a Sharjah court adjourned, a

The National

Dana Gas's application to appeal English high court order rejected

19/12/2017

Dana Gas, the Sharjah-based energy company embroiled in court battles over the legality of its US$700 million sukuk, said on Monday the English court of appeal rejected the company’s application to a

The National

Ticker Price Volume
QNBK 137.89 130,508
EACCO 27.40 60,779
SABIC 106.39 2,885,717
QIMD 44.00 4,213
BURUJ 34.81 228,528
SAAC 8.18 1,837,342
STC 70.55 156,544
DANA Sector Market
P/E
Price/BookValue
Relative Strength
  • 1-Month
  • 3-Month
  • 1-Year
Volume Change
  • 10D Avg Vs 90D Avg
Price Vs…
  • 52-w high
  • 50-day moving avg.
  • 200-Day Moving Avg
Ticker Price Change
PETRORABIGH 20.90 0.84 (4.18%)
BAHRI 30.39 0.27 (0.89%)
TAQA 0.56 0.00 (0.00%)
ALDREES 25.49 0.03 (0.11%)
SARCO 32.15 0.02 (0.06%)
CB&I announces Joint Development Agreement with Saudi Aramco

19/01/2018

CB&I has announced it has entered into a Joint Development Agreement with Saudi Aramco that includes Chevron Lummus Global (CLG), CB&I's joint venture with Chevron U.S.A. Inc., for the development, c

Press Release

Saudi Aramco, CB&I and Chevron Lummus Global sign JDA

18/01/2018

Saudi Aramco, through its wholly-owned subsidiary Saudi Aramco Technologies, has today signed a three-party Joint Development Agreement (JDA) with CB&I, a U.S.-based leading provider of technology an

Press Release

Aramco ready to IPO in H2, awaiting govt decision on venue: CEO

18/01/2018

Saudi Aramco’s Chief Executive Amin Nasser said on Thursday that the initial public offering (IPO) of the state oil giant is still planned for the second half of 2018, but the government has not yet

Reuters

Weeks of talks ‘fail to resolve Dana Gas sukuk dispute’

18/01/2018

Weeks of talks between UAE energy firm Dana Gas and some local holders of a disputed $700 million sukuk have failed to reach an agreement, sources told Reuters, leaving a potentially protracted legal

Arab News

Damac Properties founder ready to sell 15% stake at Dubai developer

18/01/2018

Hussein Sajwani, the Dubai billionaire with links to US President Donald Trump, said Wednesday he was ready to sell 15 percent of his stake at real estate giant Damac Properties. Established by Sajw

Arab News