26/09/2017 06:20 AST

Sharjah-based Dana Gas sought to have US$700 million worth of Islamic bonds declared unlawful so it could avoid repaying investors next month, London’s High Court heard on Monday, a charge the company has denied.

The company’s claim that a huge 2013 financing deal was invalid owing to subsequent changes in Islamic financial practice was “absurd”, according to documents filed by bondholders with the court.

The bondholder group, led by Blackrock, the world’s largest asset manager, was in court on Monday demanding that Dana Gas repays millions of pounds, or hand over stock in a subsidiary that runs its operations in Egypt.

It also wanted the court to ban Dana Gas from issuing any new sukuk to secure further funds for the company. Dana Gas stunned the Islamic finance community in June by declaring the $700m sukuk Sharia non-compliant just four months before it was due to repay bond-holders.

The courtroom battle is notable for the absence of Dana Gas, which has been prevented from taking part because of an injunction in the UAE.

Lawyers for Blackrock claim that the injunction had been a deliberate attempt by the company to frustrate the court hearing, but a high court judge ruled last week that the trial in London would go ahead as planned.

The complex case is being keenly watched by the Islamic finance industry, with both London and the UAE seeking to position themselves as world leaders within the sector.

“Obviously if there is an adverse judgement out of the London court it will raise a lot of questions particularly in the minds of non-Sharia investors and there are a fair amount of non-Sharia investors who invest in sukuk,” said Abdul Kadir Hussain, the head of fixed-income asset management in Dubai at Arqaam Capital, which holds some of the Dana Gas sukuk.

Any prospect of an early conclusion to the case has been disputed by Dana Gas, which has claimed that litigation could continue in the UAE whatever the ruling in London and could last up to ten years, according to court documents.

“While markets have short memories, I think this case has already negatively impacted international investor appetite for Sukuk - most likely in the corporate (Vs bank and sovereign) sector,” said Khalid Howladar, the managing director of the risk and ratings Islamic finance advisory Acreditus.

“The complexity of the sukuk industry was already an inhibitor to growth and these recent events will cause some investors to avoid the sector completely and drive up the profit rates demanded by remaining investors. Regulatory intervention is needed to restore confidence.”

Dana Gas secured $850m from international investors in May 2013 via the restructuring of an earlier $1 billion deal secured that had been due to mature in 2012. The company was unable to repay that deal because of payment delays from operations in Egypt and the Kurdish region of Iraq.

“If all had gone well, the value … would be sufficiently large that the investments would be liquidated for an amount that was at least as large” as the money invested, said Richard Handyside QC, for the BlackRock-led group of investors, which also includes investment bank Goldman Sachs.

Dana Gas made quarterly payments according to the terms of the agreement until April 2017, but announced in May that it would embark on new restructuring talks with sukuk holders because of continued cash collection problems.

The following month, it sought a court order in Sharjah arguing that it should no longer make payments because Islamic finance standards had changed making them unlawful under UAE law. The company also took legal action in the UK and the British Virgin Islands, where its Egypt subsidiary was registered, to prevent further payments to investors.

It was clear that Dana Gas’s challenge to the lawfulness of the agreement struck between the c


The National

Weeks of talks ‘fail to resolve Dana Gas sukuk dispute’

18/01/2018

Weeks of talks between UAE energy firm Dana Gas and some local holders of a disputed $700 million sukuk have failed to reach an agreement, sources told Reuters, leaving a potentially protracted legal

Arab News

Dana Gas' Sharjah Dec 25 court hearing adjourned, spokeswoman says

04/01/2018

Dana Gas, the Sharjah-based energy company currently embroiled in court battles over the legality of its US$700 million sukuk issuance, has had its December 25 hearing at a Sharjah court adjourned, a

The National

Dana Gas's application to appeal English high court order rejected

19/12/2017

Dana Gas, the Sharjah-based energy company embroiled in court battles over the legality of its US$700 million sukuk, said on Monday the English court of appeal rejected the company’s application to a

The National

Ticker Price Volume
QNBK 137.89 130,508
QIMD 44.00 4,213
EACCO 27.40 60,779
SABIC 106.39 2,885,717
TABREED 1.92 1,158,788
SAAC 8.18 1,837,342
ARNB 27.93 36,681
DANA Sector Market
P/E
Price/BookValue
Relative Strength
  • 1-Month
  • 3-Month
  • 1-Year
Volume Change
  • 10D Avg Vs 90D Avg
Price Vs…
  • 52-w high
  • 50-day moving avg.
  • 200-Day Moving Avg
Ticker Price Change
PETRORABIGH 20.90 0.84 (4.18%)
BAHRI 30.39 0.27 (0.89%)
TAQA 0.56 0.00 (0.00%)
ALDREES 25.49 0.03 (0.11%)
SARCO 32.15 0.02 (0.06%)
CB&I announces Joint Development Agreement with Saudi Aramco

19/01/2018

CB&I has announced it has entered into a Joint Development Agreement with Saudi Aramco that includes Chevron Lummus Global (CLG), CB&I's joint venture with Chevron U.S.A. Inc., for the development, c

Press Release

Saudi Aramco, CB&I and Chevron Lummus Global sign JDA

18/01/2018

Saudi Aramco, through its wholly-owned subsidiary Saudi Aramco Technologies, has today signed a three-party Joint Development Agreement (JDA) with CB&I, a U.S.-based leading provider of technology an

Press Release

Aramco ready to IPO in H2, awaiting govt decision on venue: CEO

18/01/2018

Saudi Aramco’s Chief Executive Amin Nasser said on Thursday that the initial public offering (IPO) of the state oil giant is still planned for the second half of 2018, but the government has not yet

Reuters

Weeks of talks ‘fail to resolve Dana Gas sukuk dispute’

18/01/2018

Weeks of talks between UAE energy firm Dana Gas and some local holders of a disputed $700 million sukuk have failed to reach an agreement, sources told Reuters, leaving a potentially protracted legal

Arab News

Damac Properties founder ready to sell 15% stake at Dubai developer

18/01/2018

Hussein Sajwani, the Dubai billionaire with links to US President Donald Trump, said Wednesday he was ready to sell 15 percent of his stake at real estate giant Damac Properties. Established by Sajw

Arab News